The COACH Tatum Carryall is often carried for 2 years straight and is loved for its sturdiness. Yet, some buyers report that the shoulder straps are already fraying after just a few short months of use.
- DVSS Score: 73.95/100
- Satisfaction Tier: Good
- Review Count: 110 (Validated data)
✓ STRENGTHS
- Aesthetics: Gorgeous, classy design with an “awesome red” interior lining that makes it stand out.
- Travel Size: Spacious but not too bulky, making it perfect for everyday use and travel.
- Internal Security: Features an enclosed zipper pocket perfect for securing a wallet or keys.
- Longevity: Leather is nice, and the bag is “well made,” lasting two years of daily carry for some buyers.
✗ LIMITATIONS
- Capacity Mismatch: Does not fit 13-inch or 15-inch MacBooks, despite product description claims.
- Strap Durability: Shoulder straps show visible fraying and wear after a few months.
- Logo Failure: The metal “COACH” logo breaks off the bag within less than a year of use.
- Pocket Flexibility: Internal slip pockets are “kind of useless” as they are stiff and cannot fit common items.
⚡ QUICK DECISION
You’re a STRONG FIT if you:
- Need a structured, elegant bag for daily use that holds essentials, but not a large laptop.
- Prioritize aesthetic details, especially the striking red interior, and appreciate its perfect sizing.
- Are willing to use the detachable strap sparingly, relying mainly on the main handles.
You should SKIP this if you:
- Plan to carry a 13-inch or 15-inch MacBook, as the Tatum Carryall dimensions are inaccurate.
- Require high durability, as fraying and logo detachment occur within a few months of wear.
- Need flexible internal pockets for organizing multiple small items.
🎯 IDEAL USER: Stylish professionals who prioritize a classy appearance and medium capacity for travel essentials.
⚠️ KEY ISSUE: The product dimensions are inaccurate; the bag is too small for professional laptops advertised in the description, leading to returns.
Read the full article below. ↓
Contents
Tatum Carryall: 73.95 Explained: The Structural Quality Flaw
The Tatum Carryall achieved a Good 73.95 DVSS, demonstrating high buyer satisfaction with its aesthetics and feel but severe disappointment with inaccurate product claims. The score is directly attributable to the misleading capacity and durability issues reported.
- DVSS Score: 73.95
- Satisfaction Tier: Good
- Review Count: 110 (Validated data)
- Average Rating: 4.50 stars
- Ideal For: Medium-capacity day bag for travel essentials only.
Data-Validated Satisfaction Score (DVSS) — proprietary metric weighing satisfaction, rating counts, and dissatisfaction risk. The DVSS story highlights the contradiction between the bag’s aesthetic perfection and its functional failure. The Tatum Carryall is a beautiful product, but measurement errors regarding laptop fit and premature fraying tank the score, confirming buyer risk.
Capacity Is Too Small for 13-Inch and 15-Inch MacBooks
The most critical functional flaw of the Tatum Carryall is its actual size, which contradicts the product description. Buyers explicitly report that a 15-inch MacBook will not fit, and, shockingly, some 13-inch MacBook Air models do not fit either.
The description claims the bag is 11.5″ x 15 3/4″, but one buyer measured it at only 10″ x 14″. This means the Tatum Carryall is not large enough to hold a work laptop or a large notebook, disappointing buyers seeking a work tote. One buyer reports, “It’s beautiful but really annoying that the product description says it fits 13 13-inch laptop and it doesn’t.”
This capacity limitation limits the Tatum Carryall to fitting only smaller notebooks, phones, keys, and extras, making it more like a purse than a carryall.
Key Facts:
- Actual size: Measured by a buyer at 10″ x 14″, significantly smaller than listed.
- Laptop failure: Does not fit a 15″ MacBook and sometimes fails to fit a 13″ MacBook Air.
- User frustration: Many returned the Tatum Carryall because it couldn’t hold their work laptop.
- Functional fit: Only large enough for a smaller notebook, phone, keys, and extras.
Shoulder Straps Show Fraying After a Few Short Months
While many buyers describe the Tatum Carryall as sturdy and well-made, its long-term durability is severely compromised by strap failure. Users report that the shoulder straps are already fraying after just a few short months of wear and tear.
Another durability flaw is the metal “COACH” logo, which breaks off the purse within a year. One buyer reports, “My purse is less than a year old and the metal ‘COACH’ Logo has broken off already.”
This means the Tatum Carryall is a high-risk purchase for buyers expecting years of wear. The bag may look classy, but its structural components are unreliable for heavy daily carry, leading to frustration.
Key Facts:
- Failure timeline: Straps start to fray after a few months of regular wear.
- Component failure: The Metal COACH logo breaks off within a year of purchase.
- Sturdiness: The Tatum Carryall’s straps are strong enough for daily carry initially.
- Repair issue: Buyers report reaching out to the company about fraying issues, but received no response.
Stiff Internal Pockets Are Useless for Organization
The Tatum Carryall’s organizational structure is mixed, with a middle zippered compartment and two side compartments. The zippered pocket is perfect for a wallet, keys, or anything a buyer doesn’t want to fall out.
However, the internal slip pockets are often criticized for being stiff and useless, as they cannot fit common items like phones or accessories. Buyers wish the pockets were more flexible so they could actually use them. One buyer wishes “the pockets on the inside were a bit more flexible. Maybe they’ll stretch out some in time, but as of now, they’re kind of useless.”
This means the Tatum Carryall functions mostly as a single, large compartment, relying on the central zip section for security.
Key Facts:
- Secure pocket: An enclosed, zippered middle compartment keeps valuable items secure.
- Slip pocket flaw: Internal pockets are stiff and described as “useless” by some users.
- User need: Buyers wish for more flexible pockets that can stretch to hold items.
- Compartment structure: Features two unlined side sections and one middle zippered section.
The Red Interior and Overall Style Are Highly Classy
Despite the functional flaws, the Tatum Carryall is overwhelmingly praised for its appearance and quality. The bag is described as beautiful, gorgeous, and very classy, with high-quality leather.
The “Black True Red” color is a major draw, featuring a striking red leather lining that provides a “pop of red” and “drama and flair.” This aesthetic appeal is so strong that one buyer reported carrying the Tatum Carryall for 2 years straight, refusing to change it.
The Tatum Carryall is generally seen as roomy without being too bulky, making it a sleek, structured option for travel and everyday use.
Key Facts:
- Interior color: Awesome red leather lining makes the Tatum Carryall stand out.
- Aesthetic appeal: Described as structured, sleek, and gorgeous with a classy look.
- Carrying style: Perfectly sized to hold enough stuff without being too big and annoying.
- Packaging: The Tatum Carryall came well-protected, but without a dust bag in some cases.
Is the Tatum Carryall the Right Choice for Travel and Everyday Essentials?
The Tatum Carryall is a classy, structured, and beautiful bag that excels at carrying medium loads for travel and everyday essentials. However, its misleading capacity and durability issues make it a high-risk purchase.
The core decision is whether you value the sophisticated aesthetic and perfect size more than guaranteed laptop fit and long-term strap durability.
✓ You’re a Great Fit:
- You are carrying items like an iPad, a small notebook, a wallet, and keys, not a 13” or 15” MacBook.
- You need a roomy bag that is still sleek and structured, avoiding a bulky appearance.
- You prioritize the secure, zippered middle compartment for securing valuables.
- You love the beautiful design and are comfortable with the aesthetic and quality.
✗ This Won’t Work:
- You must fit a 13-inch or 15-inch work laptop, as the bag is too small for either.
- You expect the straps and logo to remain flawless for more than a few months of use.
- You rely on the internal slip pockets for organizing multiple small accessories.
- You are sensitive to inaccurate product measurements or descriptions.
The Structured Tatum Carryall is the Classy Option for Medium-Load Travel
The Tatum Carryall is a great travel bag that is large but not too big. You can fit all your stuff without it being too bulky or annoying to carry. The red interior is awesome and makes the Tatum Carryall stand out.
Not Suitable for Professionals Requiring Accurate Laptop Capacity
This bag is not recommended if your primary purpose is to carry a work laptop due to the severe capacity mismatch. You should explore our COACH Tote bags collection for better alternatives, as the Tatum Carryall’s small size and fraying straps limit its professional utility.
The Classy Tatum Carryall Is a Beautiful, High-Risk Choice for Daily Travel Essentials
The Tatum Carryall offers a classy, structured, and roomy way to carry daily travel essentials. The primary strength is its beautiful aesthetic and secure zippered middle compartment; the key limitation is the inaccurate laptop capacity and the tendency of the shoulder straps to fray after only a few short months.
Check the current price for the Tatum Carryall. You should also explore our COACH Tote bags collection for better alternatives.
